Homo Floresiensis: Hobbits of Southeast Asia

What is Homo floresiensis? This question has plagued scientists since the 2003 discovery of these hominids in the remote island of Flores, Indonesia. A few specimens, found only inside the cave of Liang Bua in Flores, were given the names LB1, LB2 and so on. Their small stature, thought to be no taller than a three-year-old human child, led to them being nicknamed “Hobbits” by scientists after J.R.R. Tolkien's tiny “Lord of The Rings” characters. Homo floresiensis is thought to have co-existed with modern humans starting from about 18,000 years ago to about 13,000 years ago -- pretty recent in geological time. What Is The Hobbit?

Height comparison between Homo sapiens sapiens and Homo floresiensis. Illustration from www.amnh.org

Cranial comparison between LB1 (Homo floresiensis) and modern human. Photo from www.bbc.co.uk

A recent article suggests that Homo floresiensis existed alongside modern humans (Homo sapiens sapiens). If Homo floresiensis were indeed contemporaneous to modern humans, then they could have been the sourceof local myths such as the “Ebu Gogo” and “Orang Pendek”. Cryptozoology and mythology aside, scientists are still debating whether Homo floresiensis is a species of its own or just a small population of Homo sapiens sapiens that suffered from cretinism.

Putting a face to the hobbit (Facial reconstruction from LB1 cranial). Photo from www.blogs.discovermagazine.com

So who really were Homo floresiensis? A species of their own or just individuals that suffered from cretinism? We still do not know.

If Homo floresiensis were indeed a species of their own, did they evolve out of Austrolopithecine, Homo erectus or even archaic Homo sapiens?

If Homo floresiensis were actually archaic Homo sapiens suffering from cretinism, how did they survive well pass adulthood and use stone tools to hunt?

Currently there is no consensus whether Homo floresiensis were a separate species or just individuals who suffered from cretinism. What do you think?